Do You Have an Executive Presence? Use This Scorecard to Find Out

Photo by Vitaly Gariev on Unsplash

Picture this, you’re in a meeting where everyone’s suddenly talking in circles. Then, one person speaks, and the room suddenly quiets. People lean in. Their ideas land, and not because they’re louder, but because something about their presence commands attention.

That’s executive presence.

While it’s often described in vague, almost mystical terms, that natural leadership or “it factor” isn’t something you’re born with. It’s a set of skills, behaviors, and mindsets that can be observed, developed, and refined.

If you’ve ever wondered why some professionals rise faster, earn more trust, or seem effortlessly influential, chances are they’ve learned to cultivate this presence. The good news? So can you.

What is Executive Presence, Really?

Executive presence is often misunderstood as charisma or confidence, but it’s much more grounded than that. It’s how others experience your leadership, whether you’re in a boardroom, presenting an idea, or simply sending an email.

At its core, executive presence combines three key dimensions.

1. Gravitas: How You Carry Yourself
  • This is your credibility, composure, and ability to command respect.
  • It shows up in how you handle pressure, make decisions and own your perspective.
2. Communication: How You Express Yourself
  • Clear, concise, and intentional communication, both verbal and non-verbal.
  • It’s about tone, timing, storytelling, and the ability to adapt your message for different audiences.
3. Appearance: How You Present Yourself
  • Not about wardrobe perfection, but about congruence.
  • Do your presence, professionalism, and personal style align with the role you aspire to?

Think of these as three pillars supporting the same structure, credibility. Without balance, the foundation wobbles.

Developing executive presence isn’t about pretending to be someone else. Our Visibility Accelerator program is designed to help raise your visibility and build confidence to succeed in your career.

The Executive Presence Scorecard

Use this scorecard to assess where you are today. For each statement, rate yourself from 1 (rarely true) to 5 (consistently true). Be honest, this isn’t about perfection, it’s about awareness.

Gravitas
  • I stay calm and thoughtful under pressure.
  • I own my decisions and communicate them with confidence.
  • I’m known for my integrity and follow-through.
  • When I speak, people listen, not because I dominate, but because I’m trusted.

If you score below 15, your next step is developing inner authority. You can develop this through practices like mindful pausing before responding, preparing for high-stakes conversations, or soliciting feedback to strengthen credibility.

Communication
  • I speak clearly and with purpose without overexplaining.
  • My ideas are structured and relevant to the audience.
  • I use storytelling or examples to make my message memorable.
  • I read the room and adjust my tone or pace when needed.

If your score here is lower than expected, focus on clarity and connection. Record yourself during a mock presentation, or ask a colleague what they remember most after you speak. Often, it’s not the words, but the energy that you leave behind.

Appearance
  • My appearance and body language project confidence and credibility.
  • I show up prepared, polished, and professional in all settings.
  • My online presence (LinkedIn, emails, camera presence) reflects my professional brand.

This isn’t about changing who you are, it’s about portraying yourself as who you want to be. Your appearance and presentation should reinforce your ideas, not distract from them.

Presence in Action
  • I make others feel seen, heard, and respected.
  • I handle conflict with composure and fairness.
  • I bring focus to meetings rather than adding noise.
  • I leave interactions with people feeling more confident, not less.

If your responses in this category feel inconsistent, it might be time to slow down. Presence is often lost when professionals rush or multitask their way through leadership moments. Try creating micro-pauses before replying, reacting, and deciding. Those few seconds can transform how others experience you.

Reading Your Results
  • 16-20 points per category: You’re demonstrating strong executive presence. Continue refining your consistency and mentoring others.
  • 11-15 points: Solid foundation, but room to grow in self-awareness and intentionality. Focus on one small, visible habit to strengthen your credibility.
  • 10 or below: Don’t be discouraged. Executive presence is learned, not innate. Identify one key behaviour that would make the biggest visible difference and start there.

Constructive Mindset Shifts to Consider

Developing executive presence isn’t about pretending to be someone else, it’s about becoming more fully yourself, with intention. Here are three mindset shifts that can make the biggest difference.

From Performance to Presence

Many professionals equate leadership with performance, like projecting confidence or hiding flaws, but true presence comes from being grounded and authentic. Confidence grows when you stop performing and start connecting.

From Control to Composure

Influence doesn’t require complete control. The most respected leaders are composed, not commanding. They listen as much as they speak and bring stability to uncertainty.

From Self-Promotion to Strategic Visibility

Being visible isn’t about self-promotion, it’s about contribution. Executive presence amplifies when others associate your name with value, not volume.

Practical Ways to Build Executive Presence

Executive presence isn’t about having a corner office, a certain title, or a perfectly tailored blazer. It’s about how you make people feel when you lead.

  • Record yourself speaking in a presentation or meeting rehearsal. What your body language, tone, and clarity.
  • Ask for specific feedback from a trusted peer, such as, “When I speak, do I come across as confident and clear?”
  • Create a personal “anchor ritual”. Before key moments, take 30 seconds to breathe, center yourself, and recall your purpose.
  • Observe leaders you admire. Notice their pacing, eye contact, and ability to simplify complex ideas. Then, practice in low-stakes environments.
  • Align your online and offline presence. Ensure your professional brand is consistent from emails to LinkedIn posts to the way you show up in person.

As you reflect on your scorecard, ask yourself, “What energy do I bring into the room, and what do people remember when I leave it?”

Strengthening your executive presence isn’t about becoming someone new. It’s about elevating who you already are, steady, capable, and ready to lead wherever you stand.

The truth is, presence isn’t a privilege reserved for a few. It’s a skill available to anyone willing to cultivate it, intentionally, consistently, and with purpose.